Skip to content
Oddify World

Conventional Politics Triumphs Over Progressive Ideals in Thai Poll

"On one occasion, I visited a youth festival and found myself sitting next to another politician. He was grasping a pile of 100 baht notes to give away to the children, while I had arrived without gifts. How could I compete with that?"

Chutiphong Pipoppinyo was among the "orange wave" of reform-minded newcomers who shocked Thailand in the 2023 election by winning more seats for the reformist political group than any other party.

However, in the latest election, he was defeated in his seat in his constituency of Rayong to a rival from an old established family which has customarily controlled influential posts there.

"Back then we were like a storm that overwhelmed and the rival factions could not fight back. They thought I was merely a unknown candidate. The tide of support for Move Forward in the closing stages of that election really encouraged voters to opt for something new."

Now re-branded the People's Party, their aspirations that they would surpass their 2023 performance were crushed on the rocks of old-style patronage networks which have controlled provincial politics in Thailand during its modern history.

The outcomes are still not finalized, and a number of election issues are being probed, but that will not alter the final picture: a steep drop of over 20% in the count of seats won by the People's Party, and a significant rise by the conservative Bhumjaithai party, boosting its number of seats from 71 in 2023 to an estimated 193 in the 500-seat parliament now.

'They did not address me after that'

After gaining his seat in 2023, Chutiphong immersed himself in his role as MP, visiting his district attempting to tackle the challenges of his voters. But he swiftly faced resistance from those aligned with the entrenched political operators. Furthermore, he discovered he was required to provide financial support, from resources he simply did not have.

"I was invited to a women empowerment event - a frequent gathering for the residents to attend and have fun. But they informed me if I desired to come, I had to give 25,000 baht. I responded I did not possess that money. They were very unhappy about that and claimed I was unfeeling. I questioned if there was another way I could do to help out. But they ceased communicating with me again."

What he had run up against was a deep-rooted system of patronage controlled by a single family.

Rayong is most famous as part of the Eastern Economic Corridor, Thailand's biggest economic area, hosting many of the factories which drive its export-dependent economy. This has drawn outside workers from different areas, and also created an urban middle class which is more open to the reformist ideas of the reformist groups.

In 2023, Move Forward secured all five constituencies there.

But a lot of Rayong is still rural, the domain of farmers and orchard owners. This is especially the case in District 4, where Chutipong won his seat. He is a local man, but lived a number of years residing in California. The province has for decades been controlled by a single powerful clan, the Pitutecha family. This is what is referred to in Thailand as "Baan Yai" – large household – politics, and across the country it is the way provincial control has historically been managed.

Pitutechas run a large part of the regional authority.

Piya 'Chang' Pitutecha, the present family head, is the chosen leader of the Provincial Administration Organisation (PAO), a immensely influential role as the PAO oversees most official budgets in Rayong.

Until 2023, Pitutechas had always been included in the MPs elected to parliament, with one being the vice-minister for health in Bangkok.

Similar to other "Baan Yai" families they have no strong allegiance – over time they have stood for several political parties. They are also prominent in the area's economy, and, unlike Chutipong, have substantial money to distribute. It was virtually unfeasible for the first-time MP to contend.

The "Big House" utilize widespread webs of canvassers - local people who know their areas, and who mobilise voters to vote for their candidate. And while it is officially forbidden, they also distribute money throughout elections. They have traditionally been crucial to the electoral performance of provincial hopefuls, and as a recent, predominantly urban organisation, the People's Party had lacked them.

"So I adjusted my strategy," explains Chutipong. "I announced that I would try to address any complaints promptly. If your water is not flowing, your electricity has failed, your road has craters, I would respond."

"But the residents who called me in then faced coercion from the established system. Some got chastised in the village's online forum or over the PA system in the village. They were charged of introducing me - a stranger they said - into the area."

"When I sought to visit factories after hearing some complaints about environmental damage, I encountered a hostile response from nearby residents because they had been getting envelopes from these factories."

When it came to the latest election cycle, the Pitutechas had adapted after their defeat in the previous election.

In Districts 3 and 4, they ran junior members of the family, more qualified and with a diminished patriarchal aura than the established figures. In District 3 they stood under the Democrat party, traditionally their preferred political partner, but in District 4, thirty-four-year-old Chatchai Pitutecha stood under Prime Minister Anutin Charvirakul's Bhumjaithai party, renowned for its deep pockets and its skill in gaining the support of "Big House" for his side.

Chutipong was overwhelmed.

The Pitutechas regained the two constituencies back from the People's Party, even though the reformists kept three seats in Rayong.

"They would have welcomed me if I had given them money, but I could not do that permanently considering my limited resources. I had to choose whether I would be the MP they demanded, or whether I would keep my principles and see if the constituents would

CC
Written by

Christopher Carrillo

A curious storyteller with a passion for uncovering the weird and wonderful in everyday life.

Oddify World

Type to search articles.